Decide on your design. Our board is a Frankenstein theme. See the end of the post for other Halloween party ideas.

Place your prizes into the cups. In our game, each cup has a witch finger, eyeball ping pong ball, and vampire teeth.

Pre-cut tissue paper into 7” x 7” squares. For a neater look cut the tissue paper into circles.

We layered lime green or darker green with white tissue paper. This will help get the "pop" feel.

Wrap rubberbands around cups and tissue paper. Either use two rubberbands or double one band per cup to ensure the paper is tight enough.

Cover all of the cups.

Once you have planned out the cup layout, add a generous amount of hot glue to each cup and add to the foam core. Hold each cup for a few seconds to let the glue set.

Decorate your board. For this Frankenstein design, that meant adding white tissue paper eyes, drawing a nose and mouth with a permanent marker and adding black construction paper hair and bolts.